MAIL.
MAIL.
THE CORRECTNESS OF CALCULATIONS WAS NOT EXPOSED TO DOUBT - IT WAS A QUESTION ABOUT
CORRECTNESSES OF COMPARISONS.
It is compelled to pay your attention to article of journalists of T.Koshkarevoj and
R.Narzikulova ("NG" N 18 from 3.02.1999), in which in polemic with JU.D.
Masljukovym the correctness of calculations on dynamics is called into question
Industrial production in IV quarter 1998 in relation to September
The same year. These calculations are executed, as is correctly specified in interview with
J.D.Masljukovym ("NG" N 17 from 2.02.1999), Analytical centre INP of the Russian Academy of Sciences,
Which head A.Belousov has the steady professional
Reputation among experts in economic measurements. I assure you, that
Comparative calculations in relation to September are absolutely
Lawful as in September the deepest recession took place
Manufactures, and centre calculations have shown, that only in the fourth quarter
The national industry has started to creep out of a hole.
Simultaneously it would be desirable to notice, that calculations of economic dynamics,
By whatever technique they were carried out, cannot serve for measurement
Qualities of job of separate members of the government, including JU.D.
Masljukova.
I am afflicted by necessity to write this letter, as employees
Institute including the Analytical centre, are not only
Benevolent readers, but also authors of your newspaper.
Yours faithfully, the director of Institute, the Corresponding member of the Russian Academy of Sciences V.V. IVANTER
Moscow.
From "NG".
We regret for that a management of Institute economic
Forecasting of the Russian Academy of Sciences has incorrectly apprehended sense of a fragment of article in "NG" "Lie,
The half-truth and statistics ". In him any word, any phrase, even
The hint does not call in question "a correctness of calculations" experts
Institute. It was a question only of a correctness (more precisely, about an incorrectness)
Comparisons of any time piece with "any way chosen period".
For this purpose in a statistical science there are for a long time known canons and laws
Comparisons. And not to us to inform on them to so dear experts, articles
Which "NG" intends to publish on the pages.
**
The Russian Chamber of national programs and its documents.
Dear Vitaly Tovievich!.
Always considered your newspaper of objective and responsible events in an estimation,
Occurring in the Russian society.
Always considered also you as Russian intellectual suffering for destiny of the country,
Torn apart by party leaders from them "izmaticheskoj" ideology.
As suddenly. Whether publications in your newspaper on January, 27th of this year "Will risk
The president? ", on January, 28th of this year" the Call from Seleznev ", on January, 29th of this year" RPNP -
The CPSU of new time "have called, softly to tell, surprise and pressing grief from
The false estimation stated on pages of "the Independent newspaper" Tatyana
Koshkarevoj and Rustamom Narzikulovym concerning creation of the Russian Chamber
National programs.
For professional journalists it is inexcusable not to know history
The lifted subject and to base conclusions only on conjectures to please someone's
To interests.
On March, 15th, 1997 in Moscow, in "President-hotel", public
Figures, representatives of the creative unions and culture establishments,
Deputies of the State Duma and members of the Federation Council Federal
Meetings of the Russian Federation the National chamber has been founded
"Cultural property of Russia", setting as the purpose search of ways and new
Technologies in the decision of problems of preservation and development of the national Russian
Cultures. You know, what real budgetary financing was
It is defined on culture development these years. These are tears.
At creation of Chamber us moved one aspiration: the state is obliged
To give to a society possibility of definition of priorities in development,
To concentrate cumulative investments municipal, state,
The cultural, commercial organisations, the private capital, intellectual
Properties of physical persons, the western investors participating in realisation
National cultural programs.
On behalf of the constituent assembly the letter has been sent the president
The Russian Federation B.N.Yeltsin which was signed by 35 visible public
Figures, and also scientists and cultures. Among the subscribed: Irina
Arhipov, Jury Belyavsky, Vsevolod Bogdanov, Stanislav Govorukhin, Alexander
Dzasokhov, Jury Grigorovich, Michael Men, Nikita Moiseyev, Victor Sheveluha,
Igor Moiseyev, Mahmud Esambaev, Ivan Laptev, Sergey Yesin.
Idea of creation of Chamber have supported Paul Kogan, Mark Gorenshtejn, Nikolay
Petrov, Svetlana Bezrodnaja and others.
On April, 10th, 1998 the letter has been sent the president Russian
Federations B.N. To Yeltsin signed by the chairman of the Federation Council
Federal cп?п я п п?п я the Russian Federation E.S.Stroev and the chairman
The State Duma of Federal meeting of the Russian Federation N.
Seleznev which expressed support to the initiative of some the public
The organisations on creation under home nursing of the president of the Russian Federation
State-public National chamber "Cultural property
Russia ".
For 1998 we have spent set of consultations on the governmental
Level with heads of regions, with interested people in our country
And abroad, which authority we value. The set has been stated us
Wishes and offers.
Board of Chamber which has been selected at constituent conference and
To which was charged with the preparation of constituent documents, has come to conclusion,
That the Chamber should consider and form programs not only
Cultural development of a society, but also the program of the social status, that is
Complex programs of welfare development, on which performance
The state does not have either forces, or financial possibilities.
After all, look, the scientific and cultural potential in a society became
Ownerless, not necessary to the government, everyone is put before a dilemma only
The physical survival. The program scientific and technical slips
Developments, the help to the Russian scientists, art workers, practically is insignificant
Financing of national vocational schools (is stopped today on
Closing sides Moscow state is art-industrial
University of Of this year Stroganov - this world famous high school), almost
There is no financing of national symphonic orchestras, not
Presidential programs of development of historical cities of Russia are carried out,
The program "Our house" etc., etc.
Owing to what we have come to two conclusions.
The first: transition from a policy of budgetary grants is necessary for the branch
To programs to the profitable investment policy cumulative solidarizirovannyh
Financial and other investments in priority national programs
Welfare development.
And the second (in our opinion, very important): the highest result
State policy in society transformation it is possible under a condition
Connections of efforts of the state and the society. Creation
State-public associations for realisation of the national
Programs - a direct way for active attraction financial,
Intellectual and organizational resources under an end result.
As you can see, we wish to create association, anything the general not having with
Party building, also it is declared, that this
It is state-public organisation is vnepoliticheskoj and
vneideologicheskoj.
I can responsibly declare, that Chamber documents, on which journalists
"NG" build conjectures, for a long time have become outdated and have lost any legal
Value.
Chamber registration is possible only after the new constituent
The conferences which carrying out is planned on the end of March of current year.
By the way, registration of constituent documents is planned in Moscow
To registration chamber. Therefore the hearing which has been picked up by your employees on
To occasion of phone call of Gennady Nikolaevicha Seleznev in the Ministry
Justices of the Russian Federation, - a journalistic duck.
Dear Vitaly Tovievich, personally I send you a package of the constituent
Documents in full with which, I hope, you will familiarise more
In details, with interest peculiar to you.
We hope to be understood.
The application: constituent documents on 30 l. In 1 copy
With deep respect, the deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation, responsible
The co-chairman of organising committee of the Russian Chamber of the national
Programs, the secretary of the Union of artists of Russia, the deserved artist of Russia
CENTURY OF M. TARASOV.
Moscow.
From "NG".
Specially for the deputy Tarasova V. M are compelled to repeat once again:
Publications in "NG" have been based not on "conjectures", and on a package of documents,
Appeared at the disposal of edition. A part from these documents faksimilno
It has been reproduced by way of illustration in article text "RPNP - the CPSU
New time ". By the way, value of the newspaper area"NG"has not allowed us
Then to reproduce pathos product of mister Tarasova,
Which was applied on projects of authorised documents RPNP.
From its part, we will notice, that these projects have been dated quite
All relying in such cases stood concrete numbers, on them
Signatures. Therefore hardly it is possible to say that these papers could
To become outdated by the moment of publications in "NG". Certainly, in "NG" have familiarised with
"New" package of the documents sent in edition by deputy Tarasovym. Us
One really essential difference was revealed only from
"Out-of-date" variant - the processed project governmental
Than the decision became much more modest under the maintenance and inquiries RPNP,
More shortly under the form. Thus quantity of privileges and material benefits, on which
Applies RPNP, about one page of the typewritten text was narrowed. And it is difficult
To get off thought, that the governmental decree project was
It is cardinally processed after publications in "NG".
As to "a journalistic duck" we bring to the notice of the mister
Tarasova: the information on Gennady Seleznev's phone call in Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation -
It not hearing, and the fact confirmed with the ranking officer of it
Departments.
//* an information Source: the Independent newspaper, 27.02.99
//* Reg. Nom. - 1090200337.58-------------------------------------------
|
